At my baby shower I received a small stuffed animal, a blue dog with a satin belly and a collar reading"My First Puppy." I thought it was darling, but I did not even begin to dream of the love affair that would soon blossom between a baby boy and his...inanimate object!
I wasn't surprised when, at several months old, Oscar began to favor the blue puppy. The puppy is soft, cuddly, and just the right size for a small hand to grasp, just the right floppiness to fold into a small neck, and, apparently, just the right texture for a miniature set of gnashers to bite and chew, and just the right absorbency to wipe a small nose. And it's machine-washable (well, maybe that didn't factor into his choice). It quickly began to get the worn look--and worse, the goobery smell--of a cherished, rarely-left-behind comfort object. Was this attachment normal? That kid with the blanket from the Peanuts cartoon never seemed quite right to me. I consulted my book. Whew--normal. What's this though? The book suggests a spare might be in order. Uh oh. An internet search confirmed the worst: the dog was discontinued. Of course, there were several eBay profiteers ready to sell me a used one for forty bucks. Who are these people?! The best deal I could find was a new one for $25. Still no sale. I was sure I could find a cheaper solution. If a second puppy was out of the question, we would just have to convince the boy to shift his affections to an object that could be purchased in multiples.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/56f5f/56f5ff247b348a15d149b5ee1f76a49baef77a85" alt=""
For the next few months I looked high and low--ToysRUs, Target, Walmart--searching, searching, searching for the perfect lovey. Every time I saw a likely candidate I purchased two, smugly noting to myself that
two of
these were less than $25. And every time I presented Oscar with a new friend, he was delighted. He would smile, exclaim, and squeeze the plush item in a very promising manner. Yep, this is The One, I would think. But these flirtations were momentary. At bedtime or after a knock on the noggin, it was his first, true love that he sought. Even with the handwriting on the wall, I held out for several weeks, willing my scheme to succeed. During which time the price of the new puppy went up to $30--a sum I had already easily exceeded with my doomed machinations, naturally. When I was finally ready to admit defeat, I couldn't order that second puppy fast enough, and I thanked the seller for gouging me. My only regret is that we didn't get a third.